Unlocking the Mystery: Determining the Monetary Value of Currier & Ives “The Old Grist Mill” Dishes

The Royal China Company from Sebring, Ohio wanted to make dishes that were affordable and had pretty designs. The most liked design by Royal was called Blue Willow, but in 1949, they came up with a new and charming design. It was a set of dinnerware that was blue and white and had pictures that reminded people of the past. The pictures were based on the prints made by Currier and Ives. One of the Currier and Ives scene named “The Old Grist Mill” is still very popular with collectors and the value of Currier & Ives “The Old Grist Mill” dishes continues to influence the antique market even today. This even though at that time the Royal China Company made a lot of them, millions of pieces in fact!

Old grist mill structures held great importance in early American communities. They were vital to these communities as centers for food production, economic activity, social interaction, community identity, and technological advancement. These old grist mills played a crucial role in sustaining local economies, fostering social connections, and symbolizing the self-reliance and progress of these communities.

The old grist mill design represents a nostalgic connection to America’s past. Currier and Ives, a famous 19th-century printmaking firm, created prints depicting scenes of rural America, including idyllic landscapes with mills. These prints captured the imagination of the public and became an iconic representation of a simpler, agrarian era. In keeping with this fondness of the public the Royal China Company adopted the old grist mill scene as the design for their Currier and Ives dishes.

9 Ways to Determine the Value of Currier & Ives “The Old Grist Mill” Dishes

Now that you are a bit familiar with the history of the Old Grist Mill design and its significance, you must be wondering how much these dishes are worth. Determining the value of Currier & Ives “The Old Grist Mill” dishes requires a careful assessment of various factors. The specific value of these dishes can vary based on their condition, rarity, age, pattern, and demand in the collector’s market. Here’s a step-by-step approach to help evaluate their value:

1. Research and Familiarize Yourself

Begin by researching Currier and Ives dishes and their Old Grist Mill design. Understand the different patterns, shapes, and variations produced. Study reference books, online resources, and auction catalogs, as well as join specialized collector communities to gain knowledge about the history, rarity, and market demand for specific patterns.

2. Assess the Condition

Examine the condition of the dishes thoroughly. If there are defects such as chips, cracks, repairs, or discoloration, they may lower the value of the dishes. Mint condition pieces command higher values compared to those with noticeable flaws or damage. Take note of any significant imperfections as they can affect the overall value.

3. Identify the Pattern and Maker

Currier and Ives dishes were produced by various pottery manufacturers. Look for identifying marks on the dishes to determine the maker. Familiarize yourself with the different patterns featuring the Old Grist Mill design, as some patterns are more sought after than others. Note any specific details, such as pattern variations or limited editions that may affect the value.

4. Rarity and Age

Consider the rarity and age of the Currier and Ives dishes. Older pieces tend to be more valuable, especially if they are from limited production runs or discontinued patterns. It will help immensely if you research the production history of the specific patterns to determine their availability and desirability in the collector’s market.

5. Evaluate Demand and Market Trends

Assess the current demand to determine the value of Currier and Ives “The Old Grist Mill” dishes. Monitor auction sales, online marketplaces, and collector forums to gauge the level of interest and the prices at which similar items are selling. Pay attention to market trends and fluctuations in value over time.

6. Consider Provenance

The provenance or documented history of the dishes can impact their value. If you have any information about the ownership or historical significance of the pieces. This includes the dishes being part of a notable collection or having a connection to a specific event or person. These factors can add value and interest for collectors.

7. Rarity of Specific Pieces

Certain pieces or variations within a pattern might be rarer or more desirable among collectors. For example, a complete set, a rare serving piece, or a specific shape or size that is harder to find can increase the value. Research the availability and demand for specific pieces within the Old Grist Mill design to determine their individual worth.

8. Comparison and Price Evaluation

Once you have gathered all the relevant information, compare your dishes to similar items that have recently been sold or are currently available for sale. Consider factors such as condition, rarity, age, pattern, and demand to arrive at a reasonable price range for your dishes.

9. Consult Experts or Appraisers

If you’re unsure about the value or authenticity of your Currier and Ives dishes, consider consulting experts or professional appraisers specializing in antique ceramics or Currier and Ives collectibles. They can provide valuable insights, assess the condition accurately, and offer an estimated value based on their expertise and access to market data.

The value of collectibles is subjective, and prices can fluctuate based on the market and individual buyer preferences. That is why it is essential to approach valuation with a well-informed perspective and be prepared for some variation in pricing opinions. Professional appraisers from Appraisily can easily help you determine the value of Currier and Ives “The Old Grist Mill” dishes. They have decades of appraisal experience and can vouch for its worth.

Cited Sources

https://www.thriftyfun.com/Value-of-Currier-and-Ives-Plates-1.html

https://ourpastimes.com/currier-ives-plates-values-8544253.html