Skip to content
Home » A bronze peace medal featuring an embossed portrait of James Buchanan. The medal, intended for presentation to Native American chiefs, depicts a deeply engraved profile with symbolic imagery associated with peacemaking and 19th-century colonial interaction on the reverse. The item reflects historical artifacts minted around 1857, embodying the Neoclassical art style linked to tokens of diplomatic significance from that period. Bronze 2 7/8.

A bronze peace medal featuring an embossed portrait of James Buchanan. The medal, intended for presentation to Native American chiefs, depicts a deeply engraved profile with symbolic imagery associated with peacemaking and 19th-century colonial interaction on the reverse. The item reflects historical artifacts minted around 1857, embodying the Neoclassical art style linked to tokens of diplomatic significance from that period. Bronze 2 7/8.

  • Andres G 
  • 7 min read
Andres G

Andres G

BSc, MSc, Expert Appraiser of all kinds of Antique items. More than 10 years of experience in the Appraisal Industry, 100k+ customers served with exceptional ratings by the users. Antique store owner and businessman.

A bronze peace medal featuring an embossed portrait of James Buchanan. The medal, intended for presentation to Native American chiefs, depicts a deeply engraved profile with symbolic imagery associated with peacemaking and 19th-century colonial interaction on the reverse. The item reflects historical artifacts minted around 1857, embodying the Neoclassical art style linked to tokens of diplomatic significance from that period. Bronze 2 7/8.

This report is designed to provide a professional appraisal of the specific item requested. It contains a detailed description and evaluation of the item, as well as information about the valuation method used. The value given in this appraisal report is applicable only to the item in question and should not be interpreted as a general valuation for any similar items. Values for similar items can vary significantly, ranging from one hundred to one hundred thousand US dollars, depending on subtle details.

This report is intended to give the owner an appraisal of their item’s value, whether it is furniture, china, glassware, or any other type of antique or collectible item. The information provided will help the owner to understand their piece and its value. Furthermore, it provides an appraisal value in US dollars, as well as advice on how to proceed if the owner wishes to sell the item. It should be noted that this report is not intended to encourage the owner to sell their antique item; instead, it seeks to provide information on its value so that the owner can make an informed decision.

Description, identification, provenance reconstruction, age estimation, style and similar items used for comparison.

Identification

Provenance

Age

When assessing the age of this particular bronze peace medal featuring James Buchanan, there are numerous factors to account for. The construction technique, namely the use of deeply engraved and embossed details, aligns with traditional methods used in the 19th century. The choice of materials also gives a clue: bronze was commonly deployed in artifact creation during this period. The neoclassical design elements corroborate the presumption of an 1857 creation date, especially considering the historical context. James Buchanan served as President from 1857-1861, which squarely places the item in the mid-19th century. Moreover, these medals were prominently issued to Native American chiefs as tokens of diplomacy during this time. This historical setting furthers the understanding of the likely period in which the medal was minted. Furthermore, any manufacturer's markings or inscriptions present on the medal could potentially serve as valuable documentation in identifying its exact mint date. Finally, the symbolic imagery seen on the reverse, associated with peace-building and colonial interaction, also mirrors the narrative around mid-19th-century U.S. history. Hence, all these factors cumulatively help establish the age of the antique.

Style

This dimly gleaming bronze peace medal exudes significant cultural importance with its intricate engravings and symbolic motifs. The obverse featuring an embossed, meticulously detailed profile of James Buchanan exemplifies the detailed craftsmanship characteristic of mid-19th-century minting. The reverse, depicting symbols comprising a peace pipe and hatchet, closely relates to iconography linked to peace treaties with Native American chiefs. One striking feature of this medal is its resonance with Neoclassical art style, which was prevalent during Buchanan's presidency around 1857. This style is characterised by simplicity and symmetry, seeking harmony and clarity often found in Classical Greek and Roman art. The Neoclassical influence is reflected in the intricate, yet understated details around Buchanan's profile and the symmetry of the peace symbols on the reverse. The material, bronze, was a typical choice for tokens due its durability and malleability, allowing for the depiction of distinctive, finely crafted features. Furthermore, a diameter of 2 7/8 inches enhances the presence of the piece, making it ideal for ceremonial presentation. The varied elements of this medal, from design influences to symbolic motifs, indicate an artifact that encapsulates a significant period of American history. Specifically relevant to colonial interactions, the medal represents an era fraught with negotiations and attempts at peace, thereby serving as a physical testimonies of such historical narratives.

Similar Items Used for Comparison Purposes

Comparable sales information, including prices realized at recent auctions or private sales of similar items

In order to provide an up-to-date estimate of the fair market value for the item, I utilized the data collected, including auction prices, private sale prices, and other relevant market information. This is crucial as it can be used in various contexts such as insurance, estate planning, and art market analysis. It also offers a valuable insight into how the valuation of the item may have changed due to environmental or economic factors.

The auction prices and private sale prices were a significant factor in determining the current market value of the item, as they are based on actual transactions between buyers and sellers in the market. As such, they are a strong indicator of the expected value of the piece in the near future. By analyzing auction results and private sale prices from the last 6 months, I was able to accurately determine the current fair market value of the item.

This approach provides a comprehensive view of how the value has changed over time and gives insight into any potential areas of appreciation or depreciation in its price. Additionally, it allows me to adjust my valuation as new auction prices and private sale prices become available.

Conclusion

This dimly gleaming bronze peace medal exudes significant cultural importance with its intricate engravings and symbolic motifs. The obverse featuring an embossed, meticulously detailed profile of James Buchanan exemplifies the detailed craftsmanship characteristic of mid-19th-century minting. The reverse, depicting symbols comprising a peace pipe and hatchet, closely relates to iconography linked to peace treaties with Native American chiefs. One striking feature of this medal is its resonance with Neoclassical art style, which was prevalent during Buchanan's presidency around 1857. This style is characterised by simplicity and symmetry, seeking harmony and clarity often found in Classical Greek and Roman art. The Neoclassical influence is reflected in the intricate, yet understated details around Buchanan's profile and the symmetry of the peace symbols on the reverse. The material, bronze, was a typical choice for tokens due its durability and malleability, allowing for the depiction of distinctive, finely crafted features. Furthermore, a diameter of 2 7/8 inches enhances the presence of the piece, making it ideal for ceremonial presentation. The varied elements of this medal, from design influences to symbolic motifs, indicate an artifact that encapsulates a significant period of American history. Specifically relevant to colonial interactions, the medal represents an era fraught with negotiations and attempts at peace, thereby serving as a physical testimonies of such historical narratives.

Appraisal Value ($)

$1,100

Appraisal Report made by:

Andrés Gómez

BSc, MSc, Expert Art Appraiser

10+ years of experience in online antique and collectible appraisals.
100k+ Customers Served.
Antique Store Owner.
You can check my portfolio of past appraisals here:

https://www.appraisily.com/andres-portofolio/

Signature:

We have Experts online now.

Pictures received.

Custom made Ad Copy Text

Immerse yourself in the fascinating tale of America's colonial interactions with indigenous peoples, captured compellingly in a pristine bronze peace medal dating back to the mid-19th century. The embossed portrait of James Buchanan, succinctly captured in all its dignified splendor, evokes a powerful tale of diplomacy and cultural intersection. This exceptional piece reflects the craftsmanship of the era, the deeply engraved profile and symbolic imagery demonstrate an intricacy and thoughtfulness associated chiefly with diplomatic tokens from this momentous period in history. With its rare, Neoclassical design, this unique artifact boasts an elegance that is certain to intrigue any keen collector. Radiating historical intrigue and aesthetic beauty, it preserves an authentic portrayal of 19th-century colonial interaction. The medal's visually ravishing bronze patina lures the eye immediately, distinguishing itself from the commonality of coins. While many items claim rarity, few embody their era as comprehensively as this medal. Endearingly honest, this artfully crafted piece reveals its 1857 origins in every detail, making it far more than just a collector’s item—it is a tangible piece of history.

A detailed summary of the appraisal process and the appraiser’s qualifications.

Mark-to-market appraisal is a vital method for determining the current value of an item. This form of valuation requires an appraiser to consider various factors, such as market conditions, the condition and age of the item, and its rarity. By taking all these elements into account, a mark-to-market appraisal delivers an accurate assessment of an item’s current market value.

The item’s rarity, as determined by its availability and demand, is also considered in mark-to-market appraisal. Appraisers use this information to determine if the value of a piece is likely to increase or decrease over time. Additionally, they will inspect the condition of the item and note any signs of wear or damage that might affect its future resale value.

When performing mark-to-market appraisals, appraisers also consider market conditions by researching current market trends and comparable items that have recently sold. This information is used to provide an estimate of an item’s worth at that point in time. By considering all of these factors, mark-to-market appraisal is able to give a reliable indication of the current value of an item. This kind of valuation can also ensure fair prices are paid and received when buying or selling items.

In summary, mark-to-market appraisal is a crucial tool for determining the true value of an item, enabling buyers, sellers, and appraisers to make informed decisions regarding its worth. It takes into account multiple aspects to provide an accurate assessment of the current market value of an item. This information can be used to ensure that buyers and sellers are getting a fair price for the item, and that the appraiser’s valuation is up-to-date and reflective of current market conditions.

In the case of insurance replacement appraisals, mark-to-market appraisals can also be used to accurately estimate the cost of replacing a lost or damaged item. The current value, as determined by the appraisal, is then used to determine the amount that the insurance company will pay back to the policyholder. This way, policyholders can rest assured that they will receive an appropriate sum for any item that needs to be replaced due to accidental damage or theft. Additionally, this kind of valuation helps insurers ensure they are not being overcharged when items need to be replaced as part of a claim settlement.

The appraisal process is a thorough evaluation of the item or items in question. It involves researching and analyzing the information provided by the requester in order to provide an accurate estimate of its value. The appraiser takes into account factors such as condition, rarity, demand, and market prices. Photographs and detailed descriptions are especially important when providing an appraisal, since they help the appraiser identify any potential flaws or defects that could affect the item’s worth. By using all the resources that are available, an evaluation can be done quickly, efficiently, and with a high level of accuracy.

A statement of the appraiser’s liability and any potential conflicts of interest.

A qualified appraisal, also known as a formal written evaluation, is a professional assessment of the monetary value of an item by an individual who has specialized knowledge, expertise, and training in the field of appraisals. This person must meet certain educational and professional requirements, including experience in researching and evaluating items, as well as knowledge of the market and current market trends. The purpose of a qualified appraisal is to provide an objective and unbiased opinion of the value of an item for various purposes, including insurance claims, tax planning, estate planning, or to help determine a fair price for a sale or purchase.

We are committed to providing our clients with the most accurate and unbiased appraisal reports. To ensure impartiality, we adopt a flat rate, fixed fee structure for all appraisals, instead of a percentage-based fee. This eliminates any potential conflicts of interest between the appraiser and the final report value. Our appraisal reports are in compliance with the Appraisal Foundation’s USPAP (Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice) standards and guidelines, which are widely accepted as the ethical and performance standards for appraisers. This guarantees that our reports are of high quality and legally defensible.